Tessa BoaseTessa BoaseTessa BoaseTessa Boase
  • HOME
  • BOOKS
    • Press
    • Mrs. Pankhurst’s Purple Feather
      • Book Overview
      • Leading Characters
      • Women & Birds
      • Murderous Millinery
      • Suffragettes
    • The Housekeeper’s Tale
      • Book Overview
      • Meet the Housekeepers
  • THE AUTHOR
  • NEWS & EVENTS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT

The women who campaigned against the Vote

    Home Uncategorized The women who campaigned against the Vote
    NextPrevious

    The women who campaigned against the Vote

    By Tessa Boase | Uncategorized | 0 comment | 3 October, 2018 | 0

    When I started researching Margaretta Lemon, co-founder of the all-female RSPB, I assumed that she would be in favour of women?s suffrage. Of course she would!

    Etta Lemon, Mayoress of Reigate and co-founder of the RSPB

    This was a woman not afraid to swim against the current. As a girl, Etta was notorious for her budding militancy, writing stern letters to any women spotted wearing birds or feathers in church in Blackheath. By the late 1890s, by now the driving force behind the Society for the Protection of Birds, she was renowned for her public speaking and ?masculine? dominance of the field.

    Etta Lemon took on the mighty plumage trade; she lobbied for legislation to protect wild birds from what she called ?murderous millinery?. How could she not get behind the ultimate battle for equality?

    But then I discovered a letter in the Surrey Mirror. On 27 June 1908, Mrs Lemon encouraged those ?desirous of combatting the Women?s Suffrage movement? to contact her at Redhill Common. ?I have joined the Central Organising Committee of the Women?s Anti-Suffrage Association,? she wrote, ?and shall be glad if ?anti-suffrages? women in the neighbourhood will communicate with me.?

    She was, she said, of the opinion that to extend the franchise to her sex would ?work irrevocable mischief to human progress, to the British Empire, and to women themselves.?

    Mrs Lemon’s stern appeal in the Surrey Mirror, June 1908

    What was this organisation that Etta Lemon had joined, and why have we not heard of it today? The Women?s National Anti-Suffrage League was founded in 1908 in response to a petition signed by 37,000 women who believed that the vote would ?destroy, rather than add to? their special sphere of womanly influence in local government.

    The Women’s National Anti-Suffrage League badge: the image implied that well-adjusted mothers did not need the vote

    You might think that this would be a toxic invitation, something so counter-zeitgeist that no woman would be willing to put her name to it. And if you read the suffragists? literature ??both the magazines, such as Votes For Women, and the rose-tinted histories produced after WWI ? you?d be forgiven for thinking that their movement was inexorable and irresistible. But in truth it had minority appeal. The vast majority of British women had no interest in politics, in the franchise and in Westminster. Their interest lay at home. And those women who resisted the vote?(the Antis, as they became known) were, on the whole, intelligent, resourceful ? and feminist. Strange as that sounds to us today, it was not an incompatible position.

    Mary August Ward, feminist, popular novelist – and ringleader of the Antis

    Eighteen women of influence, education, breeding and energy stepped forward to serve on the Anti Suffrage executive committee, including the novelist and champion of women?s education, Mrs Humphry (Mary Augusta) Ward, and the adventurer and archaeologist Miss Gertrude Bell, an extraordinary woman by any standards (she had just published a book on her journeys through Syria, and was between expeditions to the Ottoman Empire and Mesopotamia).

    Gertrude Bell: intrepid explorer, anthropologist and anti-suffragist

    Another influential executive was Violet Markham, a wealthy social reformer passionate about women?s training and education, held by a pro-suffrage friend to be ?a real feminist?.

    And there was Etta Lemon: a woman with a proven track record in growing a society, lobbying Parliament and effective public speaking. Not having the franchise had not held her back in any way.

     

    The Times leader on 22 July 1908 celebrated the founding of the Antis, and exhorted the ladies on: ?They must fight the suffragists, male and female, with their own weapons. They must meet organisation by organisation, agitation by counter-agitation, and argument by argument.?

    Violet Markham, brilliant speaker against the Vote. She?later became a passionate convert to the suffrage cause during WWI.

    At a later Anti rally that packed the Royal Albert Hall (in direct imitation of the suffragettes), Violet Markham summed up their position: ?We believe that men and women are different, not similar beings, with talents that are complementary, not identical, and that they therefore ought to have different shares in the management of the State.?

    What happened next, is a riveting saga full of black comedy and painful ironies. The more these women agitated publically against the vote, the more they equipped themselves with political skills. And the more successful their League became (26 branches by the end of 1908; 104 by July 1910), the more the ineffective Men?s Committee for Opposing Female Suffrage plotted to take them over. This happened in 1910, masterminded by Lord Curzon (ex Viceroy of India, Vice-President of the RSPB, and tenant of Reigate Priory). He stripped the women of their power, while hanging on to their legwork and their networks ? and they were not happy.

    Lord Curzon of Kedleston: staged a takeover of the highly successful women’s Anti Suffrage League. He wanted their contacts ? and their legwork

    Mary Ward, speaking in Croydon about her dynamic ?Forward Policy? for women in local government, warned that she ?did not always agree with the arguments commonly used against women?s suffrage.? She wasn’t one of those who thought that ?the suffrage question was settled when the women who asked for the vote were bidden to go home and mind their domestic duties.?

    Millicent Fawcett, leader of the NUWSS, despaired that so many strong, articulate women were campaigning against the vote

    Meanwhile, Millicent Fawcett, suffragist leader of the NUWSS, felt great frustration about the Antis. So many were impressive women who might otherwise be pro-suffrage ??but here they were, offering a ?splendid field for chaff? with their ill-conceived arguments about separate spheres and God-ordained roles. Mrs Ward had, she felt, ?somehow wandered into the wrong camp.?

    Fawcett went on to predict, correctly, that ?future generations will probably mete out no very kindly judgment to the women who petitioned against women.?

    This alternative women?s movement has indeed been forgotten, its story now suppressed because it does not chime with the times. Yet in researching my book about the neglected female founders of the RSPB ? a hunt that took me to many unexpected nooks and crannies of society ? the untold story of the Anti Suffrage movement was one of the most fascinating and paradoxical narratives of all.

    Mrs Pankhurst?s Purple Feather: Fashion, Fury and Feminism ? Women?s Fight for Change by Tessa Boase is available from Amazon and Audible.

     

     

    No tags.
    Tessa Boase

    Tessa Boase

    More posts by Tessa Boase

    Related Posts

    • Why we need more statues of women

      By Tessa Boase | 0 comment

      ‘Mary Wollstonecraft’ by Maggi Hambling. ‘It’s a sculpture about now, in her spirit.’ Statues of women are troubling. Just look at the reaction to the 2020 Mary Wollstonecraft statue by Maggi Hambling. ‘Catastrophically wrong,’ cried CarolineRead more

    • drawing of Emily Williamson

      Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder

      By Tessa Boase | 5 comments

      Victorian campaigner Emily Williamson was so incensed by the millinery trade’s use of plumage that she invited her friends to tea ⁠— and persuaded them to sign a pledge to wear no feathers. The all-femaleRead more

    • The strange ritual of the Servants’ Christmas Ball

      By Tessa Boase | 0 comment

      Uneasy mingling: the Servants’ Ball at ITV’s Downton Abbey, where Lady Grantham rightly couples Carson, the butler ⁠— and Lord Grantham escorts housekeeper Mrs Hughes Was the Servants’ Ball really so marvellous? It is invokedRead more

    • Winter blues: did servants suffer from SAD?

      By Tessa Boase | 0 comment

      Did servants suffer from SAD ??Seasonal Affective Disorder? The Victorian diaries of Mrs Sarah Wells, housekeeper of Uppark and mother to novelist H. G. Wells, reveal the physical and emotional cost of working in subterraneanRead more

    • The Seduction of Heather Firbank, Edwardian It Girl

      By Tessa Boase | 12 comments

      A dozen feathered hats, hidden within the fashion archives of the Victorian and Albert Museum, London, were my first introduction to Edwardian fashion addict Heather Firbank. Having viewed the hats ? seductive, stylish, the lastRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    NextPrevious

    Subscribe

    Please check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

    Recent Posts

    • Why we need more statues of women
    • Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder
    • The strange ritual of the Servants’ Christmas Ball

    Recent Comments

    • Tessa Boase on Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder
    • Nick Salt on Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder
    • Molly Baer Kramer on Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder

    Categories

    • Uncategorized (16)

    From the Blog

    • Why we need more statues of women

      ‘Mary Wollstonecraft’ by Maggi Hambling. ‘It’s a sculpture about now, in her

      28 November, 2019
    • drawing of Emily Williamson

      Looking for Emily Williamson, RSPB founder

      Victorian campaigner Emily Williamson was so incensed by the millinery trade’s use

      6 November, 2019
    • The strange ritual of the Servants’ Christmas Ball

      Uneasy mingling: the Servants’ Ball at ITV’s Downton Abbey, where Lady Grantham

      29 December, 2018
    SEE THE BLOG

    News & Events

    Woman’s Hour, BBC Radio 4
    Hear all about Etta Lemon, the ‘Margaret Thatcher’ of the birding world. How did this remarkable character hone her campaigning skills, and why was she stabbed in the back by the men who took over the RSPB?

    Secrets of the National Trust with Alan Titchmarsh (Channel 5)
    Erddig Hall in North Wales was once home to the Yorkes ⁠— a family famously kind to their servants. Or were they? I uncovered the story of ‘thief cook’ Ellen Penketh, jailed in 1907 for allegedly stealing £500 from her insecure mistress Louisa Yorke.

    Radio Gorgeous interview with Josephine Pembroke, talking twitchers (why are hardcore birders almost always men?), the mysterious workings of the RSPB (why wouldn’t they let me revisit their archives?) and Mrs Pankhurst’s penchant for fashion (why so many feathered hats?).

    SEE ALL NEWS & EVENTS
    • HOME
    • BOOKS
      • Press
      • Mrs. Pankhurst’s Purple Feather
        • Book Overview
        • Leading Characters
        • Women & Birds
        • Murderous Millinery
        • Suffragettes
      • The Housekeeper’s Tale
        • Book Overview
        • Meet the Housekeepers
    • THE AUTHOR
    • NEWS & EVENTS
    • BLOG
    • CONTACT
    Copyright © 2021 Tessa Boase. All Rights Reserved.
    Author Website Design by Outbox Online
    • HOME
    • BOOKS
      • Press
      • Mrs. Pankhurst’s Purple Feather
        • Book Overview
        • Leading Characters
        • Women & Birds
        • Murderous Millinery
        • Suffragettes
      • The Housekeeper’s Tale
        • Book Overview
        • Meet the Housekeepers
    • THE AUTHOR
    • NEWS & EVENTS
    • BLOG
    • CONTACT
    Tessa Boase